The True Cost of Free Things

So there we were, a bunch of guys in their 40s on a Tuesday night, sitting around a corporate conference room table playing our once-a-month friendly game of Texas Hold ‘em.
On the big screen, the Sox were busy beating the Indians, the credenza was overflowing with pizza, Doritos and drinks, Attorney Steve was busy talking about landing a big one for his firm, CPA Rob was talking about his daughter’s birthday and somewhere at the far end of the table I could hear ultra-successful investment banker Brad mumbling about his wife demanding a pit-stop at Publix for a frozen chicken.
And there, sitting at the head of table was myself, concentrating on one thing and one thing only: staring down film producer Rod, wondering if he was trying to bluff me out of yet another hand. Believing a third rub of his eye was his tell, I called his “all-in” and heroically managed to beat his two-pair with a straight to the ten.
Although losing the biggest hand of the night wasn’t destined to be his fondest memory, I did manage to give him the bright side of things: technically speaking, the money he just lost could potentially be a tax write-off for him.
Surprising? To many people, it most certainly is. In fact, I find many people aren’t aware of the laws regarding the thing we all look forward to, sometimes referred to as “winning free stuff.”
So, while you may not find yourself hanging out with the Hold ‘Em gang on a Tuesday night, who knows? You may find yourself the proud owner of something for free. And in the event you do land such a thing, when it comes to taxes and other related issues, here’s a few quick things to keep in mind…

Given there’s a better chance for me to win PowerBall than for my New York Jets to win another Super Bowl, I suppose I should remind myself of what will happen if I got so lucky to win the biggest lottery in the land.
Generally, all lottery winnings are subject to federal, state and local taxes. An award under $600 dollars is often not reported, however, technically speaking, any amount you win needs to be reported as taxable income. Large winnings are reported on IRS form 5754 and other than swimming to
Disappointed? Don’t be. For those that don’t appreciate lengthy swims to foreign lands, you may want to consider not playing the big one at all. …. Why? … Well, consider this: PowerBall is played twice a week and the odds of winning are roughly 120,000,000 to 1 (which is close to the odds of my Jets winning another Super Bowl). Do the math, and it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to know you have a longshot to win it (for those that caught my prior statistics error, I thank you for the heads up).
That’s not very good odds, and yet another reason why you might want to consider sticking with that nice morning run around the neighborhood instead of training for a swim to Cuba.

Have you ever won a cash prize? I once did. High school, 7-11, a scratch-off-something where I think I won somewhere around $20 dollars (and no, I don’t believe I reported that to the IRS).
When it comes to winning a cash prize, this one is fairly simple: cash prizes are taxable, and as a result, federal, state and local taxes are owed on the amount you win. Typically, anywhere from 10% to 25% of the winnings could be withheld from large amounts awarded. As for the rest, you’ll have to pay the rest come tax time.

Forget Tiger Woods. A few years back, a buddy of mine once landed a very sweet hole-in-one at a charity golf tournament. Not only did he get a peck on the check from the snack girl, but he also won a brand new Porsche.
Sound good? It sure did, until he learned Uncle Sam wanted to ride shotgun. When it comes to winning product prizes, the IRS says you’ll have to pay federal, state and local tax on fair market value, rendering the peck on the cheek from the pretty snack girl the only thing you may want to actually take home with you.

Who wouldn’t want to win money at a casino? I certainly would, and if anyone out there has had the experience of doing such a thing, toss me a note about how it feels.
When it comes to winning big money, casinos typically withhold 30-40% of the winnings. Ironically, however, the tax laws are actually different depending on the game you played to win it.
See, the casinos managed to convince congress there’s no way they can possibly keep track of everyone, especially at the lower wage tables when playing blackjack, baccarat, craps, roulette or the big wheel. As a result, generally speaking, when playing at those tables, the winnings are generally not reported to the IRS – but technically speaking, the gambler is always supposed to report any winnings as money received.
And as for comps, get this: technically speaking, those things you get for free could be deemed taxable items as well. Needless to say, I don’t know of many people that report a comped surf and turf down at the Bellagio on their tax return, but once again, technically speaking, all that free stuff could be something to report as well.
Other tidbits that come to mind include:
- Bells ringing all over creation? Congratulations on your win, but winning money at slots will be reported if the amount is over $1200.
- Pick a few winners on Keno? Well done. But any amount above $1200 will be reported as well.
- Chicago Buck or Eddie’s Revenge come in first? That’s real sweet and it may even get you a date with the best looking girl on the block, but remember: winnings down at the horse or dog track over $5,000 or 300x the wager will be reported.
- If you’re like me and typically lose more than you win, here’s an important point: generally, one can write off gambling losses against their income, but only up to the amount of their winnings.
- Excess losses cannot be carried forward to the following tax year.
- Gambling at an Indian Reservation? Have fun, bring a date, win huge, quit your job, enjoy the Elvis impersonator but remember, all the rules above still apply.
- To substantiate wins and losses, the IRS requires a journal of record that states a list of items including, (1) the date and type of your wagers; (2) the name of the gaming establishment; (3) the address or location of the gaming establishment; (4) the names of the other person(s), if any, present with you; (5) the amount(s) you won or lost; and lastly, (6), whether or not you were drinking, and if you were, the type of drink you had (just kidding).

Get a Wii for your birthday? That’s great, especially since I’ll be glad to come by and challenge you to a set of tennis. But what if it was a really nice gift? The type of gift I’m talking about is the one over $12,000. Get one of those sweet somethings and technically speaking, the person who made the gift is required to pay the tax on its fair market value (note: $12,000 is for tax year 2007 only; the amount typically changes every year).
So, the next time someone wants to buy you the New England Patriots, be sure not to tell them they’ll have to pay the tax, otherwise, you’ll likely end up with the NY Jets instead.
As far as I’m concerned, ending up with the Jets and someone having to pay the tax is lame, but it is the law. But don’t despair, there are exceptions to the rule. Gifts that are generally not taxable include tuition and medical expenses paid by someone else, gifts to your spouse, gifts to a political organization and gifts to charities.

Uncle Moe was a great guy. Not only did he buy your first Nirvana album, but he also left you a few million bucks to boot. Not bad. But while a few mill is all well and good, don’t think for a moment that the other Uncle of ours doesn’t want his cut as well.
Sad, but undeniably true, even that occasionally annoying thing called “Death” can be taxed. Specifically, the type of tax I’m referring to is often called “the death tax,” or, technically speaking, the “estate tax.”
If there’s any good news about the estate tax, it’s that few families actually incur it. Statistically, only a small percentage of people will have to deal with this, but in tax year 2007, if Uncle Moe died with over $2 million, you’ll likely have to pay estate tax on the amount inherited above that “exempted” amount.
Going into details about the estate tax is far beyond the focus of this post, but it is an important point, and if it hasn’t been addressed within your family, trust me: it’s something you should most definitely look into the different ways one can potentially reduce it.

I love winning free things. After all, who doesn’t? But whether it’s landing snake eyes, a hole-in-one or someone off-loading the New York Jets, next time Lady Luck rears her beautiful head, keeping in mind the things above could be some important points to remember.
Order my brand new book today and save 5% from Amazon: You Can Never Be Too Rich: Essential Investing Advice You Cannot Afford to Overlook
If you enjoyed this post, don’t forget to subscribe to my RSS feed!



October 27th, 2007 at 7:42 pm
Hi Alan,
I stumbled upon your blog a few months and have been enjoying it ever since! This post was a real eye-opener for me because I never thought of having to pay when you win stuff. Thanks!
“Sun John”
October 27th, 2007 at 8:26 pm
So how is The Price is Right so popular if the winners are encumbered with huge bills for the items they win?
October 27th, 2007 at 8:38 pm
The sad truth is that many people that win those million dollar prizes have to sell them to pay the taxes they owe…the aftermath never makes the news.
October 27th, 2007 at 8:52 pm
Awesome post Alan, really good points. We can’t wait for your new book to come out!
October 30th, 2007 at 1:35 pm
great post. i really like the blog. thanks!
October 30th, 2007 at 1:46 pm
I really liked your post, very interesting.
Your math on the lottery odds is a bit off, well, not the math part, but the assumptions made are off. You’re assuming that a every drawing is dependent on the previous drawing which it isn’t. Just like flipping a coin 500 times and getting heads 500 times in a row doesn’t reduce the odds of heads coming up the 501st time the coin is flipped. Every single time the coin is flipped the odds are 1 in 2 that it will be heads.
Using your numbers, every single time you play the lottery and buy 15,000 tickets your odds never become 1:1, they are always 15:120,000.
October 30th, 2007 at 2:56 pm
If only free meant tax free, we’d be all be happy. I guess everything has a price. Freedom might be the costliest; monks dying in Burma or soldiers dying in a war. I came across a website about Estonia’s Singing Revolution - http://singingrevolution.com; it’s a story of thousands of people coming together and fighting fro freedom.
October 30th, 2007 at 2:57 pm
If only free meant tax free, we’d all be happy. I guess everything has a price. Freedom might be the costliest; monks dying in Burma or soldiers dying in a war. I came across a website about Estonia’s Singing Revolution - http://singingrevolution.com; it’s a story of thousands of people coming together and fighting fro freedom.
October 30th, 2007 at 3:14 pm
So those “win-a-vacation!” deals on TV are really “get a vacation at 60%-70% OFF!”, not much better than what I get faxed every day.
October 30th, 2007 at 3:30 pm
This is an interesting article. Glad you shared it with us.
October 30th, 2007 at 4:17 pm
“PowerBall is played twice a week and the odds of winning are roughly 120,000,000 to 1 (which is close to the odds of my Jets winning another Super Bowl). Doing the math, if you lived to be 77, then you would have to buy roughly 15,000 tickets for each drawing (approximately 30,000 tickets each week) to give yourself a 1:1 chance of winning.”
Somebody failed basic statistics. Financial advisor indeed…
October 30th, 2007 at 5:23 pm
move to canada.
October 31st, 2007 at 2:03 am
Yeah I remember one of those TV shows (can’t remember the name) where these people built a house for a low-income family, and they couldn’t afford to keep it because of taxes.
As for The Price is Right, I’ve heard that it’s quite often that the prizes are never accepted, since so many of those contestants are poor college students. Furthermore, you have to pay the money immediately, before you can even do anything.
October 31st, 2007 at 3:21 am
[…] The True Cost of Free Things - Alan Haft There is 2 things for certain, death and taxes… (tags: economics) […]
November 2nd, 2007 at 3:26 pm
Hi Alan,
I have been following your blog since I first saw it on digg many months ago. I am really looking forward to your book!
Fun post here. My uncle won the lottery and is now broke!
November 27th, 2007 at 1:57 pm
Cool blog.