CDs that earn over 20%? Is that possible?
Thursday, May 31st, 2007
Magician David Copperfield made the Statue of Liberty disappear. David Blaine levitates a few feet off the ground and Chriss Angel walked up the side of Caesar’s Palace.While these all seem virtually impossible, this one may seem far more unbelievable: I have a handful of clients with CDs that earned more than 20% last year.And making matters even more unbelievable, this wasn’t done through a magic trick. While I do admit to having a couple of good card tricks up my sleeve (I can even smash a coin through an unopened soda can), when it comes to these CDs, there’s no need to use any smoke and mirrors. In the case of delivering a CD that earned more than 20%, however, all I merely used was something called “Structured Products.”
“Structured Products” is the technical term for what some media refers to as “Growth CDs.” For purposes of this blog where I try to keep things simple and to the point, I’m not going to get into all the technical details of how these complex, derivative based investments work. I’m writing this merely to inform you that these things are out there and you may find them interesting enough to further investigate.
The following are some common features:
- Guaranteed protection of principal if the Structured Product is held to maturity.
- Maturity is typically 3 - 5 years.
- The guarantee is backed by FDIC insurance.
- The return one earns from a Structured Product is typically determined by the performance of a stock market index. This is exactly why the returns on the CDs mentioned above earned greater than 20% last year.
- Market indexes returns are based on might include any one of the following:
- S&P 500
- Dow
- Nikkei Index
- Various European indexes
- Commodities indexes
- Typically, a calculation will determine how the interest is credited to the account. Figuring out returns is not always as easy as saying “The S&P 500 went up 10% so I’m getting 10% on my Structured Product.” Different Structured Products calculate interest different ways and it’s obviously important to have at least some measure of understanding as to how the calculation works before an investment is made.
- In many cases, it is possible to “break” the Structured Product early. If one breaks the Structured Product early, they will typically get fair market value for it (and that fair market value can be more or less than the original investment). In addition, there could be early withdrawal penalties and withdrawals might only be permitted once or twice a year.
- In some cases, a minimum rate of interest is guaranteed at maturity even if the indexes don’t perform well.
- Interest earned is fully taxable, just like any other CD.
- Structured Product are almost always invested in through a brokerage. Local banks don’t typically offer them.
Bottom line: if you like the idea of protecting your money while investing in the stock markets, a Structured Product could be a welcomed part of your well diversified investment portfolio. And after seeing the impressive returns a handful of my clients earned last year in these investments, for the risk adverse investor understandably fearful of loss, there’s no doubt I’ll occasionally continue recommending them for some time to come.


Legend has it that just before the 


